The taste is correct but the texture is a little dry and crumbly which just makes a mess more than a cookie especially when it is supposed to be a “cake”. My biggest peeve is that the cookie is the same size as the opening to the container which makes it impossible to get it out without a completely crumbling and breaking all over the place. Overall, I give this one star, they are too dry and crumbly, and break way too easily that you might as well just eat a bucket of crumbs.